Defensive Score Sheet: Michigan 79, Michigan State 70

Russell Byrd's matador defense late in the first half proved costly
for the Spartans as the U-M stole momentum and never looked back. (AP)
It's always an interesting game within a game: The Turning Point.

Listen to commentators for forty minutes and by the final buzzer there will have been at least a half dozen turning points that lead to Team X defeating Team Y. (Of course, some of those turning points had Team Y beating Team X but were negated when something else happened).

Pick the turning point from Michigan's 79-70 win against Michigan State - a win that makes this the first Wolverines senior class to have a winning record vs. the Spartans (6-2) since the 1996-99 seniors:

  • Option A - 1H, 9:57 (MSU 22, Michigan 11): Michigan goes into a 1-3-1 zone. Keith Appling drives and kicks to Gary Harris who hits a 3-pointers...except Appling is called for an offensive foul - his second - and sits the rest of the half. Michigan proceeds to go on a 10-0 run over the next four minutes.
  • Option B - 1H, 2:18-0:39 (MSU 31, Michigan 24): Russell Byrd checks in to give Alvin Ellis III a blow. Byrd proceeds to play his worst defense of the year. First, Caris LeVert breaks Byrd down on a jump shot. Next, Glenn Robinson, sensing a mismatch, takes Byrd to the hole for an And-1 (he missed the free throw). Lastly, LeVert takes Byrd to the rim, makes a basket and gets fouled. He converts the 3-point play.
  • Option C - 1H, 0:01 (MSU 36, Michigan 31): After MSU's Gary Harris hits a jumper with five seconds left in the half, Caris LeVert beats MSU's defense down the court and hits a 3-pointer at the buzzer.
  • Option D - 2H, 14:17 (MSU 48, Michigan 43): The Nik Stauskas show really begins heating up with a 3-pointer. Stauskas had already scored five points in the half, but it was this triple that started a stretch where Stauskas alone went on a 11-4 run. MSU never led after Stauskas' 3-pointer at the 10:04 mark to give U-M a 54-52 lead.

Every single option listed above (and potentially others not listed) could be the turning point. I would vote for Option B. Michigan State had dominated the first half so much (it's eFG% was close to 70 percent) that a few defensive stops would have changed both locker rooms at halftime. Instead, MSU continued to excel on offense only to watch its defense falter. While Izzo's man-to-man defense does utilize help occasionally, there is no denying Byrd got owned again and again and again. Every play was demoralizing for the Spartans.

I can't second guess Tom Izzo there as he was giving Kenny Kaminski a blow (Kaminski came in to replace Byrd after the final of the three straight woeful defensive possessions). He was likely doing the same thing with Alvin Ellis but was probably going with Byrd's size advantage (6-7 vs. 6-3).

While LeVert's 3-pointer before the half hurt and Stauskas' takeover was huge I believe both would have been minimized in terms of effectiveness had the Spartans held a bigger lead. They didn't because of those three-straight Brydisms.

Here's the defensive score sheet from No. 20 Michigan's 79-70 win against No. 13 Michigan State:

Extra Notes

  • Keith Appling is not 100 percent. He's not even 80 percent according to Coach Izzo. This begs the question: Would Spartan fans rather have a back court of Travis Trice and Denzel Valentine at 100 percent or a 70-percent Appling? Remember, Appling was victimized by Stauskas' great shooting Sunday afternoon but it's his offense (or lack thereof) that is hindering the Spartans. He scored six points, but all came in the final 100 seconds as Michigan was leading by double digits and playing ole defense so not to foul. Appling had three uncontested layups when the final whistle sounded but he did little else offensively. The ball seemed to die in his hands at the top of the key and he's not a threat to shoot so it's like playing 4-on-5, right? 
  • This will probably be the last Russell Byrd sighting this season. That 176.5 DRtg is borderline unconstitutional in East Lansing. When Branden Dawson returns next week against Illinois the first guy to be relegated to scout team duty is likely Byrd. That 3-point dagger against Iowa seems like eons ago, doesn't it?
  • How often have I said Caris LeVert's motor defensively can change the game for Michigan. He was spectacular Sunday, forcing four missed shots and four turnovers. He allowed 3.5 baskets - two of which were late closeouts on 3-point shooters Gary Harris and Denzel Valentine, but no Spartan was able to get a bucket dribbling by the lanky LeVert. He was as active defensively as I've seen him all season.
  • Zak Irvin is good for one thing: offense. When he's not hitting 3-pointers he's just giving other player a quick rest because he's a defensive liability. He only played seven minutes against the Spartans - mostly because he wasn't shooting well and John Beilein knew it was best to cut his losses.
  • The whole "wait until Michigan State gets healthy" narrative has run its course. Keith Appling won't be 100 percent the rest of the season. However, the defense should return to form when Dawson returns. It probably isn't a surprise that MSU is 18-1 with Dawson in the lineup and 4-5 without him when you look at the defensive numbers. The Spartans have given up at least 1 point per possession in eight of the nine games Dawson missed (only a 60-58 loss at Wisconsin [64 possessions] missed that mark). It happened just five times in MSU's first 19 games with Dawson in the lineup. Those are just the fact, folks. It doesn't mean MSU goes from slumping to Final Four favorite but it does mean the Spartans will get a dynamic boost on the defensive end. 
The Defensive Score Sheet Project's initial explanation is here. More concise explanations are in this post, but here is a short rundown:
  • Min - Minutes played
  • DREB - Defensive Rebounds
  • FM - Forced field goal miss (includes blocks)
  • FTO - Forced Turnover (steals, charges taken)
  • FFTA - Forced missed Free Throw Attempt
  • DFGM - Allowed Defensive Field Goal Made
  • DFTM - Allowed Free Throw Made
  • DRtg - Defensive Rating (Gives players credit for stops and scoring possessions)
*The DRtg is most important part of a defensive score sheet as it is the analog of an offensive rating. If a player was on the floor for 100 of his team's defensive possessions, the DRtg calculates the number of points the opposition would score.

[NOTE: Deuce2Sports' defensive charting has been noted on Sports Illustrated's Web site twice this season by college basketball writer Luke Winn.]